L'Oreal True Match: I started using this when I was in university as it was the only drugstore foundation pale enough for me. I used this foundation up until my discovery of Bourjois Healthy Mix in 2011. I'd still recommend L'Oreal True Match but it's very heavy on your face and isn't that long lasting.
MAC Lipstick in Hue: I went through many many tubes of this lipstick and looking back it looked awful on me. It's way too light for my skintone and just washed me out.
LORAC Blush in Peach: I wore this blush religiously throughout university and would finish one pot in about 3 months! It started breaking me out a few years ago so I think they changed the formula.
The Body Shop Liquid Eyeliner: This was the liner I wore the most when I was in university. It started to annoy me since it smudges so easily.
Nars Eyeshadow Duo in Key Largo: Another item I loved as a student and god knows why I would spend so much on eyeshadow when I was on a tight budget. It is a lovely duo though I just don't think I could spend that much on 2 eyeshadows again.
Bonne Bell Lipsmackers: The item that got me into makeup. I think everyone loved these as a preteen. They are way too sweet for me now but I did buy these for my preteen cousins for Christmas.
MAC Mineralize Skinfinish Natural: This is a nice powder but you don't get much product for your money. I also found that it didn't last very long on my face.
Bourjois Volume Glamour: This used to give me perfect bold and curled lashes but it just doesn't work for me anymore.
Dove Sensitive Essentials Day Lotion: This was such a nice light and gentle moisturiser. So sad it's discontinued :(
Revlon Colorstay Mineral Finishing Powder: Revlon claims this is still for sale but I haven't seen it in years. It was the perfect and subtle shimmer powder.
Benefit Snap Out of It Scrub: This was an amazing scrub that smelt like honey. I have yet to find anything like it.
Maybelline Mineral Power Concealer: The best concealer ever and I know other people loved it too. Why did you discontinue this Maybelline!? It was perfect for both blemishes and under eyes and was so cheap.
Maybelline Mineral Power Blush: Again, why Maybelline!? Why!? This blush was so pigmented and long lasting.
What products have you fallen out of love with or miss?